NACST Online Members' Resources - NACST Newsletter
back to main

Newsworthy, NACST newsletter highlights

September 2003 [current]
Contents:
from the President: LABOR DAY STATEMENT 2003 - The Best of the Underpaid
The Value of the John J. Reilly Memorial Scholarship
NACST Convention: 25th Anniversary
Among the Locals - no summer vacation from union work
ACT on Strike [Update: Strike Settled]
From the Editor: The The Bottom Line
The Union Advantage ... by the Numbers
U.S. Mint Teachers' Network "Coins in the Classroom" Contest
Red Ribbon Week 2003
Low-Income School Teachers' Student Loan Forgiveness Program 
Previous Issues
 
The 25th NACST Convention

October 10-12, 2003
New York City

Keynote Speaker 
Dr. David Gregory, St. John's University, School of Law
teaching courses in Labor Law, Advanced Labor Law,
Employment Law, Employment Discrimination
coauthor: Labor-Management and the Law
editor: Labor and the Constitution
Labor Law
Dr. Gregory frequently serves as a media commentator on labor, employment, and constitutional law issues.

Top of Page
 
Among the Locals - no summer vacation from union work

BATA - congratulations and best of luck to Lew Pedi, incoming president who replaces Bob Anspach.  Special thanks to Bob for the many years at the helm of BATA, especially during the Archdiocese's attempts at "spinning off" schools and the negative impact of the priests' sex abuse scandal in Boston.

DETA - president Sue Manzella reports that one Buffalo elementary school negotiations ended in teacher ratification of a three year contract with pay increases of 6.25% in the first year, 6.25% in the second year and a wage re-opener in the third year.  The union has filed a grievance in another school on behalf of a teacher whose hours were cut back, with loss of tenure and benefits.

SRTA - negotiations successfully concluded at St. Rose in Belmar NJ for teaching staff and the teacher aides have now gotten recognition and begun the negotiation process.

STEA - the newest chartered local is St. Theresa School in Harrisburg PA.  The local is the first unionized school in the Harrisburg Diocese and the union has met with the pastor and superintendent to begin the process of recognition and collective bargaining.  Congratulations to president Deborah Foote.

UCCEA - congratulations to president Ellen Piccolo and the teachers at Our Lady of Peace in New Providence NJ for the successful conclusion of negotiations leading to their second contract.

YCDT - president Barb Demesko reports that the Youngstown high school teachers  ratified a three year contract, and elementary school negotiations will begin this November.

Top of Page

from the President

LABOR DAY STATEMENT 2003 
The Best of the Underpaid

     As I write this Labor Day Statement 2003, the 1000 + members of the Association of Catholic Teachers, Local 1776, who work in the 22 high schools of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, are walking a picket line.  During the last two months of the past school year, these teachers had worn buttons stating WE WILL IF WE HAVE TO. Unfortunately, they had to.

     On Tuesday, September 2nd, they voted 3-1 to reject the contract presented to them. The basic issues are medical premiums, salary, early retirement provisions and some nonmonetary working conditions. The teachers on the line are unified, strong and resolute. They want the School System to know that they are feeling a lack of respect both for themselves and for the job that they do.

     Throughout the entire negotiations, the Association’s Negotiating Team and the teachers have been hearing from the School System that, ”according to a survey of 72 dioceses conducted by the National Association of Catholic School Teachers, the Archdiocese’s secondary school teaching salaries rank among the highest in the nation. The starting salary of $30,300 was the third highest in the survey and the  maximum salary was the sixth highest in the survey.”

     What I say to the various TV and newspaper reporters who bring this up is that Philadelphia Archdiocesan high school teachers are among “the best of the underpaid.” There are still teachers in non-unionized schools in other dioceses whose salaries would qualify them for food stamps. Starting salaries of $13,000 and $14,000 with BA Maximums of $16,000 and $18,000 certainly register too low to be detected on the social justice scale.

     Much has been written about the Catholic Church as an employer. Most of it reads very well, but it somehow seems to break down when it needs to come off the page and into the pocketbook. In many cases, when you add in due process and job security, you go beyond breakdown and enter meltdown.

     I wish all teachers in Catholic schools a happy and productive year in the classroom. For those who will be at the bargaining table this coming school year and for those, like the teachers in Philadelphia, who still are, I pray for a fair and just settlement, a settlement that truly reflects the social justice teachings of our Church.

Top of Page
 
ACT on Strike

ACT members at 22 Philadelphia Archdiocesan high schools went on strike September 2.  The strike affects nearly 23,000 students in the Archdiocese.  The vote was 669 to 231 to strike.

The main issues were salary & employee contributions to health care.  The Archdiocese offered teachers a three-year deal with pay increases totaling $3500 per teacher over the life of the contract.

At the same time the diocesan offer increased teacher payments to the health benefits plan, with no cap for teachers on increases in the second and third years of the pact.

Teachers voted down the proposal stating that the small salary increases would barely cover the potential increases in medical insurance.

Negotiations resumed three days after the strike began.

ACT members last went on strike was in 1997.  That strike lasted 10 days.

[Update: The 2003 strike was settled September 15, with teachers returning to classes Tuesday September 16, following the two week work stoppage.]

Top of Page
 
The Union Advantage ... by the Numbers
union workers earn higher wages and get better benefits than
workers who don't have a union voice on the job

Median Weekly Earnings
Union workers  $740
Nonunion workers $587
Union wage advantage 26%

Women's Weekly Earnings
Union workers $667
Nonunion workers $510
Union wage advantage 31%

Guaranteed [defined-benefit] pension
Union workers 69%
Nonunion workers 14%
Union pension advantage 53%

Health Benefits
Union workers 75%
Nonunion workers 49%
Union health benefits advantage 26%

Short-term Disability
Union workers 69%
Nonunion workers 30%
Union disability coverage advantage 39%

Life Insurance Coverage
Union workers 82%
Nonunion workers 51%
Union life insurance advantage 31%

sources:
US Dept of Labor, Employment & Earnings January 2003
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employee Benefits in Private Industry 2000

Top of Page
 

From the Editor: The Bottom Line

     In media reports of the current ACT strike, an Archdiocesan spokesperson stated that if parents were at the negotiation sessions they would want three things: the students to return to school; the teachers treated fairly; and, the tuition to be affordable.  Striking ACT members want the same three things.  So, what's the solution?

     The position stated by the Archdiocese is characteristic of diocesan/school administrators' thinking about financing Catholic education.  The problem is that it assumes the schools should be financially sustained by underpaid teachers and [sometimes] financially strapped parents.  The assumption is wrong and contrary to the Church's teaching.

     Reliance on tuition and low salaries [with benefit packages for which teachers are expected to pay] will never achieve economic justice for teachers and parents.

     The solution: dioceses and schools must simply follow the US Bishops' teaching - the obligation to sustain the church's institutions - education and health care, social service agencies, religious education programs, care of the elderly, youth ministry and the like - falls on all the members of the community because of their baptism; the obligation is not just on the users or those who staff them (#351, Economic Justice for All, 1986, NCCB).

     Diocesan financial support of Catholic education is an element of responsible stewardship in the Church.  Financial support of the schools is not a "subsidy."  It is an integral part of the Church's social justice mission.

     How long will dioceses ignore the bishops' own teaching?  How much longer do diocesan officials believe teachers and parents can carry the burden alone?

     Until dioceses become active participants in the financial support of the schools, justice for teachers and parents will remain an unattainable ideal.

     To all diocesan officials who hold the position stated by the Philadelphia Archdiocesan spokesperson the message is clear and simple: practice what the bishops teach.

Top of Page
 

THE VALUE OF THE JOHN J. REILLY SCHOLARSHIP
The John J. Reilly Memorial Scholarship was established to help defray the cost of a college education for outstanding children of NACST members. During their senior year of high school, $5,000 awards are made to three students, $1,250 for each of their four years of college study.
The scholarship honors and is named for the founding president of NACST.  The following letter was received from one of the first recipients.

July 11, 2003

Dear President Schwartz and Executive Committee Members,

I wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for your financial support this year.  With the assistance of the scholarship money from the NACST, my freshman year of college has been truly amazing.  I love being at the George Washington University, and I look forward to continuing my studies as an International Affairs major there.  I successfully "graduated" from the Elizabeth J. Somers Women's Leadership program, a prestigious living and learning community at GW.  I am also please to announce that I have been named to the Elliott School of International Affairs' Dean's list for both the fall and spring semesters this year.

While it may seem like only cutting a scholarship check for you, the support of the NACST has meant a lot to me this year; I wanted to succeed and to show you how proud I am to have received the first John Reilly Scholarship.  Thank you so much, and I look forward to our continued relationship.

Sincerely,
Christine E. Caggiano
SDACT

Top of Page
 
For the 2003-2004 school year:
‘Unite for a Drug Free World - Plant the Promise!'
Red Ribbon Week 2003

     Red Ribbon Week  raises awareness and rallies communities to fight drug, alcohol and tobacco use among youth.
     To make participation both simple and easy, NFP has teamed up with TulipWorld.com, an award-winning Dutch bulb site to offer on-line bulb packages designed to suit every climate and budget.
Packages can be viewed  here.

Top of Page
 
U.S. Mint Teachers' Network "Coins in the Classroom" Contest
     The U.S. Mint offers a variety of programs and services for teachers in grades K through 8.  The government department has established the U.S. Mint's H.I.P Pocket Change Website to make its services easily accessible.
     In order to promote the Mint's programs a "Coins in the Classroom" contest is being held through mid-October to recognize the most exciting and innovative methods of teaching with coins.  The contest offers prizes worth a combined value of nearly $700 as well as national recognition.
     Participants will submit lesson plans which will be judged on their educational content, clarity, originality, accuracy, and their connection to coins.  Click here to access the website and to participate in the contest.
     The major goal of the contest is to maximize the quality of educational resources available at the Mint's website.

Top of Page
 
Low-Income School Teachers' Student Loan Forgiveness Program 

     Participation in the teacher student-loan forgiveness program is available not only for teachers in low income schools but also in two other categories.  Those other categories are teachers of students with disabilities and teachers of subjects in which the State Education Agency has determined that there is a "teacher shortage."
     For a listing of the cancellation/deferment options available go here.
     Further information is provided at the FSA HELPLINE  1-800-433-3243 (1-800-4FEDAID) and
here.
     To check if the school in which you are teaching is a designated low-income school go here
     To check if the subject you are teaching has been designated by your state as having a teacher shortage go here.

Top of Page

Previous Issues
June 2003  April 2003   December 2002  September 2002 
June 2002April 2002  Decembet 2001 September 2001
April 2001February 2001December 2000September 2000
April 2000 September 1999 December 1999
 

Newsworthy is a publication of the National Association of Catholic School Teachers.
Direct comments, inquiries to: Chris Ehrmann, NACST, Suite 903, 1700 Sansom St., Philadelphia, PA 19103 email nacst.nacst@verizon.net.

Back to Main | Newsletter | Bulletin Board | Affiliate Listing
Executive Committee | Legal Defense Fund

dy>